Donald Carr calls himself a human becoming. On June 23rd, 2021, he told the truth about his childhood to a panel of judges, and he won.
The Jamaican-born storyteller, artist and coach took first place at Speaker Slam® Fathers 2021, an online competition held around Father's Day by North America's largest inspirational speaking competition. Forty speakers entered. Ten reached the final night, and Donald finished at the top.
"I feel like I'm being reborn while I'm young," he said when his name was announced. "It's a great thing to feel trusted and be validated by others who listen. I'm looking forward to being more acquainted with you all, because I think I belong here."
A Human Becoming
Donald describes his own beginnings in a few short lines. Nature blessed him with a Jamaican birth. His mother blessed him with an educated mind. Adolescence overtook him in Toronto.
"I learned that sometimes the door that opportunity knocks on has to be built by yourself," he wrote.
He is an artist first. His educational, spiritual and community-building work shaped his sense of purpose, and he now works as a transformational coach for mind, body and soul. His aim is to inspire men and women to confidently own their stories so they can live their best life now.
"I'm into touching minds," he wrote earlier in 2021. All he asked of an audience was an open mind. "Minds are like parachutes. They only function when open."
Father: No Him, No Me!
His speech, "Father: No Him, No Me!", asked for exactly that. It was written like a poem and performed like a piece of theatre, and it began on the night of his ninth birthday.
"When I was a little boy, my molester, a man I had known all my life, never forced himself upon me," Donald said. "He didn't have to. He was my hero."
He called that man the beast. For a few lines he let the audience hear the beast's voice, then he stepped back into his own and turned to his father, a Black man who rose in the corporate world.
"My father had black skin, but he wore a white mask so well that he overcame the soft bigotry of racism's low expectation and moved on up the corporate ladder," he said. "When I looked in his eyes, I never saw myself reflected."
What followed was a life of holding it in. "The mind forgives. The body never forgets," he told the judges. For years he hid what had happened, and he described the cost in one image.
"Each lie I told became another nail hammered into my heart."
The speech turned when Donald chose to stop hiding. He began to tell the truth, regardless of the cost, and he turned his rage into courage.
"Each time I told the truth, I pulled another arrow from my wound," he said. "Truth, like sunshine, is the best disinfectant."
Then came the line at the heart of the speech.
"I can tell you, it is much easier to bring up healthy boys than to repair broken men."
In the final scene he turned to face the beast, "the man I still love," and found his rage had melted. He ended with his own son, who took his father's face in his hand and told him the nails were all gone.
"Yes, my son," Donald answered. "The nails are all gone, but the holes are still there."
The Fathers Podium
Fathers took place online on June 23rd, 2021. Ten finalists, chosen from 40 entrants, each shared a five-minute speech about the fathers who shaped them. The judging panel was Brian Miller, Danielle Tucker, Julian Doan and Tracy Schmitt.
- Donald Carr, "Father: No Him, No Me!"
- Julianna Bootsman, "A Father's Prayer"
- Alma Tarelli, "Love Doesn't Need Words"
For the full night, see the Fathers 2021 recap and meet the speakers.
Donald Carr's Speech: "Father: No Him, No Me!"
Below is the transcript of Donald Carr's winning speech, presented online on June 23, 2021.
Donald's speech describes childhood sexual abuse.
When I was a little boy, my molester, a man I had known all my life, never forced himself upon me. He didn't have to. He was my hero.
When he climbed into my bed that first time, on the night of my ninth birthday, I at last had his total attention.
Said the beast, "Here. Have some Guinness. Put some hair on your chest. It's your birthday. I suppose you wouldn't, because I'm offering it. You think I'm repulsive? I know I'm no bloody Mr. Universe, but just now and again you might show some interest in me for a change, for Christ's sake. Why don't you give me a cuddle? Just relax. Close your eyes. It's never going to work out if you're so uptight. All right. Shall we have another game?"
When I was a boy, I looked up to my father. My father had black skin, but he wore a white mask so well that he overcame the soft bigotry of racism's low expectation and moved on up the corporate ladder. Father was considered successful.
When I looked in his eyes, I never saw myself reflected.
I know. No him, no me. But beneath my skin, a velvet rage consumed me.
The mind forgives. The body never forgets.
Hurt people hurt people.
It was not until the day that I learned that my son had been molested that I was finally able to face up to the fact that I had been robbed of a chunk of my childhood by a man I trusted.
Even though I had wiped clean the evidence of tears, the shame, the pain still clings.
I saw it all. Innocent lambs led to the slaughter. I watched, wide awake in a nightmare.
Now I know what monsters dream of. Humans.
Truth is vital to my survival. I had to face up to the sad realization that my life was a living lie. Each lie I told became another nail hammered into my heart.
I took many walks on the wild side. One purple, bruised soul I pawned in exchange for oblivion. But Novocaine could not mainline my pain away. Tombstones grew up in my eyes.
Finally, I said yes to life. Began to tell the truth, regardless of the cost. Turned my rage into courage.
Each time I told the truth, I pulled another arrow from my wound. Truth, like sunshine, is the best disinfectant.
The wisdom we gain is paid for by our pain. And I can tell you, it is much easier to bring up healthy boys than to repair broken men.
The day came. My heart was finally rid of the vice of lying. The board was empty. All that remained were holes.
But hell is other people. There was no exit. The home was where the hell is.
So I turned to face the beast, the man I still love.
The beast smiled. I was blinded by the light. There was so much beauty in the beast. All my rage melted.
I cried, "Father, all I wanted was your love. All my dreams was that you would love me. Now in my soul, where you used to be, there's a hole into which I fall, day and night. Father, I miss you like hell."
Ali took my face in his hand. Silent, wiped my silent tears.
"Father, you should be happy today, yet you weep over grievous memories. What grandfather did was not your fault. Never was, never will be. I'm happy for you. You've stopped lying, and the nails are all gone."
"Yes, my son. The nails are all gone, but the holes are still there."
Donald Carr
Transformational Coach for Mind, Body and Soul, Storyteller, Artist
Donald Carr is a storyteller, artist and transformational coach for mind, body and soul. Born in Jamaica, he came of age in Toronto. He describes himself as "a human becoming" and says he learned early that sometimes the door opportunity knocks on has to be built by yourself.
His educational, spiritual and community-building work shaped his sense of purpose as an artist. Today he inspires men and women to confidently own their stories so they can live their best life now.
What Came Next for Donald
First place earned Donald a spot in the 2021 Grand Slam, where the top speakers of the year competed for the title of Inspirational Speaker of the Year. He took the stage at the Paradise Theatre in Toronto that December as one of the finalists, with a speech called "ReBirth: The Third Miracle."
He kept telling his story. In 2022 he reached the top four at the online Healing competition with "What You Can't Say Owns You," and he contributed a chapter to Our Yellow Brick Road, an anthology written by members of the Speaker Slam® community.