Nesh Pillay walked onto the Lula Lounge stage with a red letter A pinned to her top. Five minutes later, she had turned the harshest thing anyone had ever said about her into a speech about what women owe each other.
The entrepreneur, marketer and writer placed second at Speaker Slam® Gratitude 2019 on September 17th, the final qualifier of the season for North America's largest inspirational speaking competition. It was only the start. Two months later she stood on the podium again, this time at the Grand Slam finals.
A Writer Born Under Apartheid
Nesh describes herself as a values-driven entrepreneur, marketer and writer who hopes to never find herself on Dateline or Candid Camera. She was born in South Africa at the peak of apartheid, and she has always been hyper-aware of the gaps created by race, culture and gender. Closing those gaps drives everything she does.
The world is her stage, as her 2019 speaker bio put it. When she was not performing, she could be found teaching her three-year-old butt jokes.
That mix of candour and humour shaped the speech she brought to Gratitude.
The Scarlet Letter
"I am an awful mother," Nesh began.
Her speech, "The Scarlet Letter," started on a kid-free Saturday morning on a green velvet couch, reading messages that showed her what some of the people she loved most really thought of her. "Have you ever been punched in the gut by someone holding a razor blade?" she asked. "That's what it feels like."

She believed them. She had stepped away from her marriage, she had no predictable income, and she was sure her daughter deserved a better mother. She told the audience, plainly and without self-pity, about the moment she tried to end her life, and about the unexpected thing that stopped her. The plastic bag she reached for had one word printed on it. "Winners."
The room laughed, and so did she. "This sends me into hysterics," she said. "I rip the bag off my head and I laugh."
From there the speech turned outward. Nesh turned to The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne's story of a different woman in a different time who was also judged as "not the right type of woman," and asked the question at the heart of her talk. "What is the right type of woman?"
Stay-at-home mothers are called anti-feminist, she said, and working mothers are called absent. Women are too fat, too skinny, too bossy, too meek. "It's exhausting," she said. "And we can't just blame men for this, right?"
"When we inevitably fail, we throw stones at each other," she told the room. "But we pretend that we're throwing flowers, because that way we get to mask the condemnation as concern."
Then she rewrote her own letter. She was not married anymore because she walks away from situations that make her feel inferior. She did not have a job, but she had a business she built herself. And when her daughter fell, she let her get up on her own.
"I want her to learn to pick herself up, like her mother does," Nesh said, "and just like my mother did."
Her mother had worn an A too, she said, the awful single mother. "But let me tell you, that woman, she's A for audacious, and I'm so grateful for her."
She ended on the night's theme, and on a laugh. "Above everything else, I'm grateful for a very funny plastic bag."
The Gratitude Podium
Gratitude took place on September 17th, 2019 at Lula Lounge in Toronto, the last qualifier of the 2019 season. Ten speakers competed on the theme of gratitude before a panel of four judges, Dani Kagan, Mary Morassutti, Stuart Knight and Dr. Stephanie Estima.
- Gaby Mammone, "The Power of a Loot Bag"
- Nesh Pillay, "The Scarlet Letter"
- Ian Tyson, "Feed My Life"
For the full night, see the Gratitude 2019 recap and the speaker lineup.

Nesh Pillay's Speech: "The Scarlet Letter"
Below is the transcript of Nesh Pillay's second-place speech, delivered live at Lula Lounge in Toronto on September 17, 2019.
Nesh's speech discusses suicide. If you or someone you know is struggling, call or text 9-8-8, Canada's suicide crisis helpline, available 24 hours a day.
I am an awful mother.
It's a kid-free Saturday morning, and I'm sitting on my green velvet couch, shaking, poring over texts, finally seeing the subtext I had missed. The veiled criticism. The piqued interest in my agenda. The concern for my daughter.
I learn in no uncertain terms that I'm not a good person, not a good woman, not a good mother.
Have you ever been punched in the gut? That's what this feels like. Have you ever been punched in the gut by someone holding a razor blade? That's what it feels like, knowing that these are the closeted whispers of some of the people I love most in the world. It cut.
I'm hurt, but I don't question it for a moment. I mean, of course. Of course. Listen, if the people you trust most in this world think that you're the worst, then you're the worst. There's no denying it.
I mean, it is all true. I stepped away from my marriage. My daughter doesn't have a stable home anymore. I don't have a predictable income. I've been this way for years. And when my daughter falls down, I didn't even rush over to pick her up. I mean, it's all true.
And I know my daughter deserves better. She deserves the best kind of mother, the right kind of mother.
So I don't hesitate. I open a browser, and I search how to kill myself.
Now, Google's a little bit of a trickster, because when you search for suicide instructions, you don't get instructions. You just get a list of websites telling you why you shouldn't kill yourself. Not helpful.
And there's no time to read. There wasn't time to think. I need to figure this out by myself.
I'm against guns, so those are out. And I don't know what the lethal dose of gummy worms is, but I'm pretty sure I don't have enough.
Then, light bulb. I run to the laundry room, and I grab a plastic bag. And I sit down. This is it. The end of my life. I have to kill the world's worst mother.
I place the bag over my head, and I think about my little girl's perfect face, and take a deep breath. My final breath.
This is when it dawns on me that you can't actually kill yourself this way. It's just not how it works.
But as I'm sitting here, the minutes ticking by, I'm a little bored. So I start to read the bag.
I didn't know that would get a laugh.
The plastic reads, "Winners."
I had the same reaction. This sends me into hysterics. I rip the bag off my head, and I laugh. Like, I'm crying because I'm laughing so hard. This is so ridiculous. Like, this goes against everything I believe in.
I mean, yeah, sure, I'm now A for awful. But what is this scarlet letter?
It's from a story. Do you know it? It's by Nathaniel Hawthorne. It's about a different woman in a different place at a different time who also is not the right type of woman.
But what is the right type of woman?
We know that if you're kind of a virginal saint, you're still a prude. Although if you're anything else, you're a [expletive]. Stay-at-home mothers, they're anti-feminist. Although working mothers are absent mothers, and their kids are going to grow up to resent them. We're too fat. We're too skinny. We're too bossy. We're too vain. We're too opinionated, not opinionated enough. We're too meek.
It's exhausting.
And we can't just blame men for this, right? Because we put, and we abide by, these unattainable, ill-defined standards for womanhood. And when we inevitably fail, we throw stones at each other. But we pretend that we're throwing flowers, because that way we get to mask the condemnation as concern.
"Oh my God, did you see Susie's Insta? Who's watching her baby?"
In Hawthorne's book, the A stands for adulterer, and the red means sin. But who says it has to?
I mean, sure, I'm not married anymore, but that's because I walk away from situations that make me feel inferior. And yes, I don't have a job, but I have a business, one that I built myself, with my own hands and my heart and my brain.
And when my daughter falls down, I don't pick her up, because I want her to learn to pick herself up, like her mother does. And just like my mother did. Because my mother, she wore an A too. You know the type. The awful single mother.
But let me tell you, that woman, she's A for audacious, and I'm so grateful for her.
But above everything else, I'm grateful for a very funny plastic bag.
Nesh Pillay
Entrepreneur, Marketer & Writer
Nesh Pillay is a values-driven entrepreneur, marketer and writer who hopes to never find herself on Dateline or Candid Camera.
Born in South Africa at the peak of apartheid, Nesh has always been hyper-aware of disparities created by racial, cultural and gender differences. Everything she does is driven by the desire to close that gap.
What Came Next for Nesh
After Gratitude, Nesh entered the first-ever Wild Card Race, a week-long public vote held that September, and earned her place in the 2019 Grand Slam: Inspirational Speaking Finals. On November 20th, 2019 at the Lyric Theatre in Toronto, in front of 600 people, she placed second and finished the year as Speaker Slam®'s #2 Inspirational Speaker of the Year.
Her story did not end there. After a traumatic brain injury in 2022 erased much of her memory, Nesh rebuilt her life, and that journey became the documentary 50,000 First Dates: A True Story, which includes footage from her time on the Speaker Slam® stage. Read about the documentary on Prime Video.